100,000+ US users threshold

H.R. 10364 names VPNs alongside broadband providers and DNS resolvers. Providers serving fewer than 100,000 monthly users or subscribers in the United States are excluded from the bill’s definition of a covered service provider. The proposal has been introduced in Congress, but it is not law.

H.R. 10364, the American Copyright Protection Act of 2026, was introduced in the US House of Representatives on 14 September 2026 by Rep. Darrell Issa and referred to the House Committee on the Judiciary.

The bill would create a federal process for copyright owners to ask a court to designate certain overseas websites as foreign piracy sites and, in a second step, seek orders requiring named internet intermediaries to restrict access to those sites from the United States.

No VPN is required to block websites under H.R. 10364 today

As of 26 September 2026, the bill has been introduced and referred to committee. It has not been enacted. The blocking obligations described in this article are what the proposal would create if it became law in its current form.

What would the American Copyright Protection Act do?

The proposal is aimed at online locations operated outside the United States, or whose location cannot reasonably be determined to be within the United States. A copyright owner could bring an action in federal district court asking for a declaration that an accused online service is a foreign piracy site.

The bill says the copyright owner would have to prove the required elements by a preponderance of the evidence. Among other requirements, the court would need to find that the operator is outside the United States or could not be located there after a reasonable investigation, and that the service meets one of the bill’s piracy-focused tests.

A site would not be blocked simply because someone alleges infringement

  • A federal court would first have to issue a declaration that the target is a foreign piracy site.
  • The copyright owner would then petition for a blocking order naming specific service providers.
  • Named providers would have an opportunity to appear and respond before an order is issued.
  • The court would consider factors including technical feasibility, burden and potential incidental harm.
  • An order would apply to the providers named in it, not automatically to every VPN or internet service.

The bill defines a qualifying foreign piracy site around services that are primarily designed for infringing material, have only limited commercially significant non-infringing purpose or use, or are marketed to promote copyright infringement.

Why are VPNs part of the proposal?

The most significant detail for VPN users is in the definition of service provider. H.R. 10364 expressly includes broadband internet access providers, DNS resolution providers and virtual private networks. Root nameserver operators and top-level domain registries are excluded.

The bill also excludes an entity that provides services to fewer than 100,000 monthly users or subscribers in the United States. That means the proposal is not written to cover every small VPN service.

Explicitly included

Virtual private networks

VPN providers are named directly in the bill’s definition of service provider, subject to the exclusions and court process.

Explicitly included

Broadband providers

Broadband internet access services are also within the proposed definition.

Explicitly included

DNS resolvers

Providers of domain name resolution services are included alongside VPNs and ISPs.

Excluded

Providers below the threshold

Entities serving fewer than 100,000 monthly US users or subscribers are excluded.

Important distinction: the 100,000-user threshold does not itself create a blocking duty. A qualifying VPN would still need to be named in a court order before the order applied to it.

How could a VPN end up under a blocking order?

The proposal sets out a multi-stage process rather than an automatic government blocklist. The main steps would be:

  1. Copyright owner files a federal court action The rightsholder asks a district court to declare an accused foreign online service a foreign piracy site.
  2. Court decides whether the statutory test is met The copyright owner must satisfy the bill’s requirements by a preponderance of the evidence.
  3. Rightsholder petitions for a blocking order The petition identifies service providers the copyright owner believes are needed to reduce access from the United States by a commercially significant amount.
  4. Named VPN or provider can respond The court must provide at least 14 days for a named service provider to appear and respond before an order is issued.
  5. Court considers whether the provider should be included Factors include burden, technical feasibility, efficacy, incidental harm to other services or users, harm to the copyright owner and public benefit or harm.
  6. Named provider implements the order If included, the provider would have to take commercially reasonable steps to prevent users or subscribers from using its systems to access the designated site from the United States.

The implementation date would generally be set between 14 and 30 days after a provider receives notice. An initial order could last no longer than 12 months, although the proposal includes a process for extensions.

What safeguards does the bill contain — and why are critics still concerned?

Supporters and critics disagree sharply over whether the proposed safeguards are sufficient. The bill’s sponsor says the framework provides due process and protects legitimate online services, while digital-rights groups argue that court-ordered blocking can still create risks of overblocking, privacy impacts and disruption to lawful services.

IssueWhat the bill saysWhy it is being debated
Who decides?A federal district court would make the foreign-piracy-site declaration and issue any blocking order.Supporters point to judicial oversight; critics question whether the process sufficiently protects absent or affected third parties.
Technical methodThe court may not prescribe or require a specific blocking method or technology.That gives providers flexibility, but leaves practical questions about how VPN-specific blocking would be implemented.
Collateral blockingThe court must consider potential incidental harm or interference with other online services and users.Opponents argue that internet blocking can still affect lawful services when infrastructure is shared or identifiers change.
Provider burdenThe court must consider implementation burden and technical feasibility, and the bill provides a mechanism for certain cost reimbursement.Providers could still face engineering, legal and operational work to implement and maintain orders.
Correcting mistakesThe bill provides procedures for providers and qualifying third parties to seek modification of an order.Critics argue that restoring access after an erroneous or overbroad block can itself impose costs and delay.

Rep. Issa’s office says the proposal is intended to give copyright owners a tool against foreign piracy while including safeguards for legitimate sites, users and service providers. The Motion Picture Association and a range of copyright and entertainment organisations have expressed support for the legislation.

Public Knowledge opposes the bill and warns that site blocking could produce overblocking and impose costs on internet intermediaries. Re:Create has also argued that including infrastructure providers, DNS resolvers and VPNs creates privacy and collateral-damage risks. Those are advocacy positions rather than findings by a court, but they identify the main objections likely to shape debate over the bill.

What could this mean for ordinary VPN users?

If the bill became law and a user’s VPN provider was later named in a blocking order, the most visible effect could be that a court-designated foreign piracy site no longer loads through that provider for users covered by the US order.

The bill does not expressly require VPN companies to keep browsing histories, inspect the contents of encrypted traffic or use a particular filtering technology. In fact, it says an order may not prescribe a specific method, technique or piece of equipment for implementation.

The biggest VPN-specific question is implementation

A VPN changes the network location visible to websites, so the phrase “access … from the United States” raises practical questions for VPN providers. The bill defines the required outcome but does not spell out how a VPN must determine which connections fall within a US blocking order.

That does not mean the bill automatically requires new logging. It means the privacy and engineering impact would depend heavily on how individual providers choose to implement any order and how courts apply the “commercially reasonable” standard.

Could VPN users simply switch servers or providers?

The bill is written around reducing access from the United States rather than around one particular VPN server location. It does not describe a specific technical enforcement method, so it is too early to say exactly how individual VPN providers would handle server switching, account location, payment country, IP geolocation or other signals.

Providers below the 100,000-monthly-US-user threshold are excluded from the statutory definition, but that does not necessarily mean every smaller or free VPN would remain permanently outside the system. User counts can change, and the legal meaning of the threshold would ultimately depend on the enacted text and its application.

What happens next?

H.R. 10364 is currently at an early stage of the legislative process. It would need to advance through Congress and be enacted before its site-blocking framework could take effect. The current text states that most provisions would become effective six months after enactment.

For VPN users, the details to watch are whether the VPN language survives future amendments, whether the 100,000-user threshold changes, and whether lawmakers add more explicit rules around geolocation, privacy or technical implementation.

Frequently asked questions

Could VPNs be forced to block websites in the United States?

Potentially, if H.R. 10364 became law in its current form. A federal court could name a qualifying VPN provider in an order requiring commercially reasonable steps to prevent access from the United States to a court-designated foreign piracy site. The bill is not law as of 26 September 2026.

Which VPN providers would the bill cover?

The bill includes virtual private networks in its definition of service provider but excludes entities providing services to fewer than 100,000 monthly users or subscribers in the United States.

Would every VPN have to block every piracy website?

No. The proposal is based on court orders targeting specific foreign piracy sites. A qualifying VPN would have to be named in an order before that order applied to it.

Would the bill force VPN providers to keep browsing logs?

The text does not expressly require browsing logs or mandate a particular filtering technology. It requires named providers to take commercially reasonable steps to prevent access from the United States and leaves the technical method to the provider.

How long could a blocking order last?

An initial order could last no longer than 12 months. The bill includes a process allowing a copyright owner to seek extensions of up to an additional 12 months at a time when the statutory requirements are met.

Can a VPN provider challenge its inclusion?

Yes. A named provider would have an opportunity to appear and respond before the order is issued, and the bill also includes a procedure for a named service provider to later ask the court to remove it if circumstances materially change.

Is the American Copyright Protection Act already law?

No. H.R. 10364 was introduced on 14 September 2026 and referred to the House Committee on the Judiciary. As of 26 September 2026, it remains proposed legislation.

Martin Needs, VPN and cybersecurity reviewer

Written and reviewed by Martin Needs

Director at NeedSec LTD and Lead Technical Assessor for FindCheapVPNs. Martin covers VPN privacy, network security and the technologies used to protect internet traffic.